Rated 4.2 out of 5 by 25
Rated 5 out of 5 by Casey Great shirt.
The flannel is a great shirt. great pattern. The slim fit is definitely smaller and tighter than your average JCrew Large so beware if you've never owned a slim fit from this company.
October 13, 2015
Rated 1 out of 5 by Thomas Poor Quality
This shirt fits true to size, looks great, is very soft, but the quality is terrible. I bought this shirt 1 week ago and within that time two of the buttons on the shirt crumbled apart. They did not just fall off, but actually crumbled. I expected better quality from J. Crew factory.
October 30, 2015
Rated 5 out of 5 by PMark Love love love
I bought this shirt wanting a great fall/winter flannel that I could wear and found this. I wear it way more than I should due to just how much I love it. The fit is wonderful, the fabric is so soft, yet keeps me warm, while never too warm. It is great for layering. Definitely a great part of anyone's wardrobe. I highly suggest.
November 4, 2015
Rated 3 out of 5 by Dayt Poor Quality and Runs Very Large
I ordered the overcast blue, medium slim fit flannel. This shirt is pretty soft and the colors are great, but for being a slim fit, it is by far the largest medium I have ever worn. It fits like a regular sized LARGE shirt as opposed to anything close to a MEDIUM slim fit. Slim fit, not so much. I would order a size down. I am a broad shouldered, built guy and this shirt still didn't fit me. I can only wear this tucked in with a vest or else it looks rediculous. I also noticed that after wearing the shirt only once the top button is already beginning to fall off. Poor sizing, poor quality. Not what I was expecting from J. Crew.
February 8, 2016
Rated 1 out of 5 by Robaire Regular size mismarked as slim?
I liked the look and feel of this shirt but it was definitely not the slim size that I ordered. I have another JC slim shirt that fits perfectly. This one is at least 3 or 4" larger around the waste. JC was great about returning it; I didn't have to pay return shipping.
I'd noticed a QC problem with JC t-shirts - some are more slim than others and some are longer than others. Since this is not the first time I'd run into QC problems I thought I'd let others know.
Hopefully they can get their QC problems under control so I can feel more comfortable buying from them again.
January 9, 2016