Rated 3.7 out of 5┬áby 3
Rated 4 out of 5┬áby DredManniken Great Shirt
I would disagree with the other review. This shirt has consistent sizing with the rest of the J Crew Mens Shirts. I am 5 Ft 8 tall and I never tuck this shirt in, always untucked. My GF loves the style of this shirt and short sleeves are great for summer. The oxford fabric is one of my favorite textiles that J Crew uses in their button down shirts. Highly recommended.
July 19, 2015
Rated 2 out of 5┬áby JABIII Very long - Can only be worn tucked in
I purchased this as a summer shirt to be worn both tucked on hot days in the office and untucked for a more casual look. Unfortunately, the shirt runs a bit larger than expected overall and MUCH longer than expected so that it cannot be worn without tucking it in. When worn with shorts, the shirt almost covers the shorts completely. Because the small is even a bit large on me, when tucked, the shirt bunches a bit around the waist and doesn't look great. I'll probably be returning this one.
June 23, 2015
Rated 5 out of 5┬áby Babs Great quality
Cotton is thick and great quality. Ordered it for my husband and he loves it. Runs true to size
August 3, 2015