Rated 4.7 out of 5 by 22
Rated 4 out of 5 by LSLA1 Great color and quality but runs large
I am 5'7, 115 lbs, slender build. I am always an XS or 0 in JCrew tops/bottoms. I purchased the 0 Tall in the blue. The length was perfect for a pencil skirt, mid-knee length. However the skirt was a whole size too big. I exchanged for a 00 Tall. The length and waist are great, but still runs a slightly big through the hips/legs. Not as snug of a fit as I prefer in pencil skirts. The quality and feels great and the color is gorgeous. Just be aware if you are a slender build, this skirt runs on the larger side.
September 22, 2015
Rated 5 out of 5 by PaulaG Perfect Black Skirt
I have been in love with J-Crew pencil skits for years. It's practically every skirt in my closet. I had bought this one in yellow last year and glad to now have it in black. Will be a fall/winter staple for work. I love the thick fabric and texture of this skirt. Fully lined and nicely tailored. Material also makes it very forgiving of problem mid section. Also great value for price. I cannot wait to get this skirt in additional colors. Can't recommend this enough.
September 30, 2015
Rated 5 out of 5 by GabyA Perfect Cool Weather Pencil Skirt
I absolutely love this skirt. I have the blue and camel and both are gorgeous colors. I love the material of the skirt. It definitely will be warm for cooler weather. I usually have issues with wool, but because the skirt is lined, I didn't have any issues with this. It's very comfortable. It definietly runs big. I normally wear a 4 in pants and skirts, and I wear a 0 in this skirt. I tried on several sizes in the store before I bought it online, which I recommend.
October 15, 2015
Rated 5 out of 5 by JBeanner Perfect Fall/Winter Pencil Skirt!
Absolutely love this skirt, I purchased in both the cream or oatmeal color and Black. Fits true to size, I am 5'4" 118 lbs, athletic build and purchased a size 0P.
October 13, 2015
Rated 4 out of 5 by Grace Pencil Skirt in Double Serge Wool
The skirt ran a little small on me and I think that's why the lining tends to stick out a little at the front bottom of the skirt. I'm a fairly curvy hourglass (5'3" size 8) and bought the size 8. The fabric is nice and a good weight for work etc. It hits me a little on the shorter side, but again I think that's more due to my weight than the skirt itself (I think it's made to hit more at knee length, but hit me just above).
January 2, 2016