Penny loafers
Fits true to size based on
- 100% leather.
- Leather/rubber outsole.
- Spot clean.
- Imported.
- Online exclusive.
- Item BS114.
Reviews
Fits true to size based on
116 customer reviewsFilter reviews 1 - 6 of 116 Reviews
What customers are saying:
These penny loafers are getting a lot of love for their classic, polished look and versatile style, working well with everything from jeans and chinos to dress pants and suits. Many customers found the leather quality and overall craftsmanship to be strong, and the shoes were often described as a great value. Fit feedback is mixed, but a lot of customers suggested sizing down a half size, while a few recommended sizing up or staying true to size depending on foot shape. Several customers also noted that the loafers feel best after a short break-in period, then become very comfortable for everyday wear.
Generated from the text of customer reviews.
Jdny
Age: 55 to 64Body Type: AthleticHeight: 5'7"Size Purchased: 7.5Fits true to size
Classic penny loafer
July 8, 2026Just simple and classy penny loafer ! Comfortable
Helpful?JET06
Review submitted for promo eligibility.
Age: 35 to 44Size Purchased: 10.5Fits small
Great Shoes!
June 23, 2026Beautiful wine color but you have to size up at least 1/2 a size they run a little small
Helpful?Bufalinoo
Review submitted for promo eligibility.
Age: 25 to 34Body Type: AthleticHeight: 5'10"Size Purchased: 8Fits big
Silhouette is so premium
June 18, 2026Such a premium look and feel,I may have went a bit to tight though,if you don’t like them super snug don’t go a full size down
Helpful?Lamar V
Review submitted for promo eligibility.
Age: 35 to 44Body Type: AthleticHeight: 6'0"Size Purchased: 12Fits true to size
Classic Loafers That Elevate Any Outfit
May 10, 2026These penny loafers are exactly what I was looking for. The quality feels premium right out of the box and the leather has a clean, timeless look that works with almost everything in my closet. They are comfortable, stylish, and have that classic J.Crew look that can be dressed up or down easily. I’ve worn them with chinos, dress pants, and even dark jeans and they always pull the outfit together. As someone transitioning from a long Air Force career into the next chapter of life, I’ve been focused on refining my wardrobe and investing in pieces that look polished and versatile. These loafers fit that perfectly. They give a professional and confident look without trying too hard. The craftsmanship and attention to detail are noticeable, especially for the price point. What I appreciate most is how comfortable they became after a short break in period. Some loafers can feel stiff, but these molded well and now feel great for dinners, events, meetings, or everyday wear. They have that timeless style that never really goes out of fashion. J.Crew continues to impress me with clothing and footwear that balances quality, style, and wearability. Definitely one of my favorite purchases and I’ll absolutely continue adding more J.Crew pieces to my wardrobe.
Helpful?Review submitted for promo eligibility.
Age: 55 to 64Body Type: AthleticHeight: 6'2"Size Purchased: 13Fits true to size
Pretty Happy Overall
April 17, 2026Nice shoes, but they're stiff as others have noted, and the soles are really slick and slip while walking. One shouldn't have to go out and buy accessories to alleviate that.
Helpful?JennaLyonsFanGirl
Review submitted for promo eligibility.
Age: 35 to 44Body Type: AthleticHeight: 6'1"Size Purchased: 11Fits big
Leather is stiff, not sure if it will give
March 25, 2026My husband was really excited about these Penny Loafers but the leather on them made them feel a bit too wide and if they had any give, it would feel too loose. Returning.
Helpful?