Would give it 5 stars but it doesn't matter h the tartan blazer. The skirt itself is absolutely beautiful and a great weight and fit!

I had to purchase a size way larger than necessary, but I'm having it tailored. Worth it!

I love this skirt. The style and fabric ( black watch night) will never go out of style. You can wear always. Such a great buy.

I bought this skirt in a 8 which is my regular size.. I loved the green tartan print. I got the skirt and it wouldn't come up over my hips and thighs so I was kind of sad. Since it was final sale, I decided it had to be the lining of the skirt so I ripped the lining out and lo and behold the skirt fits perfectly. The lining is either made too small in comparison to the size of the skirt and/or doesn't have any give. But it's ok now I'm happy and can wear this gorgeous skirt!

Love the skirt, quality and fit. Happy I got it for a good price!

Fits true to JCREW sizing which is vanity sizing. The plaid is beautiful and much richer in person than the screen shows. I love the way it fits but think the material could have been much thicker than it is considering the price point. I understand this is the factory quality but that does not support lackluster quality. I honestly think if this got slightly hitched on the something it would rip. However, I do like the skirt and can see it being dressed up or down easily.