This wasn’t great. It looked a bit too childish in person.

Perfect casual skirt that can be dressed up or down. Looks really cute with a t-shirt or a blouse to wear to work. It's a great length and the waist looks fancy even though it's elastic.

Skirt is fantastic! Lined, with pockets and just the right length. Order a size down, as it runs smaller but not super small. Would love to see MORE colors for fall and winter!

I like how it fits and looks but the fabrics wrinkles super fast. I steamed it and by the time I get to work, the entire front is wrinkly from sitting. The fabric also carries hair/lint which is very noticeable in black so I recommend carrying a lint roller with you. It pairs well with all my tops which is why I like it. I'm also 5'10'' and it's not short at all. Perfect for work!

Love this skirt. Bought the red one last year and loved it!!! This year I got the black and navy. So classy and sporty at the same time. I get so many compliments! JCrew Factory, keep this as a staple please!

Based on reviews I ordered the smaller of my two typical sizes, and found the skirt to be much shorter than I was expecting and the waist fit tighter than I prefer. Exchanged in-store for two sizes larger than my original order. (Though the sizing seems inconsistent based on all the skirts I tried on, so it seems a bit of a crap shoot finding one that is an ideal fit.) It is a cute skirt though and very comfortable. The waist has the "soft" type of elastic that does not bind or constrict. The pockets are great too (though not having pockets is a deal- breaker for me.) Like others have said, the fabric is just so-so. I can live with it but it is a bit scratchy and stiff, so that you have to be okay looking a little puffy (i.e., it is not what I would consider flattering.) I am super-skinny (not in a good way) so I don't mind having the extra volume. I would not have paid full price but am very glad to have added this to my wardrobe for less than half the original price.